Movie Review: The Curious Benjamin Button Case

 

Father Scott Fitzgerald, the Real Benjamin Button. So sad. :(

It is obvious that one of the biggest movies of this movie season has been Brad Pitt’s The Curious Benjamin Button Case. With the exception of maybe those weird guys that always wore black in school and liked horror movies, most moviegoers found this movie to be incredibly endearing. Who knows? Maybe some of the horror movie fans would like it, too, but it is doubtful that they saw it.

The Curious Benjamin Button Case is about a man named (you guessed it!) Benjamin Button, but the movie is not, as many of us had suspected, a courtroom drama. In actuality, the ‘case’ is a medical case, a famous one, one that was considered curious by medical people of the time because Benjamin Button was the first person to be recognized as even having this disease, so that’s why it’s famous. Instead of being born a baby and growing old like everyone else, Benjamin Button has a disease that causes him to be born an old person and age backwards. When his mom dies giving birth to Benjamin, his dad realizes how hard being a single dad would be, so he takes the baby to an orphanage for elderly people. The rest of the movie is about the rest of his entire life, basically.

Brad Pitt based his movie on the true life of a man named Father Scott Fitzgerald, whose life story was published in the 1920’s (although he changed the character’s name from his own to Benjamin Button, I think it can still be considered an autograph). Mr. Pitt has updated Father Fitzgerald’s life story to include modern times because it’s doubtless movie goers would want to see an entire movie set in olden times. The movie also doesn’t mention anything about him becoming a priest, but I suppose Mr. Pitt wanted to focus more on the disease itself, the effects of it on the individual and those who love him, and not have a movie about praying and beads.

Brad Pitt Tells Older Actress How To Do Her Scene

Mr. Pitt takes on the role of Benjamin and plays him from an old man to a child. He’s not all that handsome as the old Benjamin, but he does get cuter as the movie goes on. Oh, and he does take his shirt off, so that’s worth waiting for, too. An older actress, Cate Blanchett, plays the woman Brad Pitt marries and then leaves because she is getting older and he is still hot. She sort of narrates the movie in that she talks over the movie while it’s playing. Unfortunately, she is the one person you can’t turn around to in the theater and go ‘Shhhhh’.

X-Man

From the beginning, it is evident that Benjamin Button has some pretty amazing powers. For one, he can’t be killed as evidenced by him surviving wars, motorcycle speeding, storms and sleeping with hookers. I was wondering if Benjamin’s having powers was because of how popular Hugh Jackson’s character X-Man has been on so many movie websites, that maybe Brad Pitt used this theme as a way to attract the super hero fans. The only way Benjamin Button can get more power to stay alive, though, (and this was the saddest part of the movie, in my opinion) is to suck out the life of someone nearby. He has to kill his mom when he is born in order to live, then he has to kill a priest in order to get enough power to walk, then he has to kill his boat friends* in order to survive an attack by a submarine army and so on and so on. Mr. Pitt’s Benjamin spends the entire movie managing to stay one step ahead of the police, so that he doesn’t go to jail for his crimes.

My only real complaints about the movie aren’t technical like, ‘oh, the lighting was bad’ or ‘those shoes are the wrong decade’ or ‘there’s too much butter on this,’ they’re just things I thought to myself or overheard other people say that I thought sounded right. Firstly, I wished Mr. Pitt would have focused a little attention on the policemen who were, more likely than not, chasing what they thought was a serial killer. It would have been interesting to see their reaction when, after decades of chasing Brad Pitt, they finally catch up with him and he’s a baby and then they can’t arrest him because he’s in diapers! Secondly, I would liked to have had the movie focus more on Benjamin’s later life when Mr. Pitt was handsome and less about his being old because I think it is harder for most movie audiences to even like the main character if they are old.

Brad Pitt Plays As An Old Man Baby

Mr. Pitt is really passionate about causes and I think Benjamin Button was made as a way of saying, although it can be cute sometimes, this disease is real and we should do something to find a cure because the babies that look old aren’t very cute.

I give Benjamin Button 4 out of 5 winks.

*NOTE – It wasn’t until seeing this movie that I learned that tattoos have been around since my grandparents’ time. That’s so cool!

The Original Hot Topic Employee!


Similar Posts:

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

This entry was posted by Valerie Atherton on Wednesday, February 18th, 2009 at 7:05 pm and is filed under movie reviews . You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
  • SarJo

    The tattoo thing totally thru me too.
    Good work, Val!

  • http://www.slashfilm.com RJ

    Your the worst reviewer in history. Do us all a favor and stop writing. You cant comprehend anything about this movie.
    Please go back to shopping for a living.

  • http://www.sizzlesays.wordpress.com sizzle

    I haven’t seen this movie because I’ve been told you’ll never get those three hours back of your life.

  • bomberbec

    Val, this is the most sensitive review of this film I’ve read.
    I totally agree that a cure should be found for this disease, I mean, sure some babies are a bit crinkly when they’re born, but ben the button was REALLY REALLY UGLY, even tho he’s brad pitt. I thought his mum died of shock on seeing him, but now I go with your sucking life force idea – why didn’t this get explored further in the film??
    Re horror fans prob not seeing this film. I like sci-fi a lot, so of course I wanted to see Brad pitt looking young and pretty more.
    When the film finished, my first reaction was (quite loudly) “How the bollocks did they string out such a tediously long film from a SHORT story”. Fortunately I wasn’t as annoying as the teenagers next to us, who were bored witless. They should probably have gone to see Bolt instead, but it isn’t out yet.

  • Wolverine fan

    Uh, his name is HUGH JACKMAN for one.

    And his character’s name is WOLVERINE.

    Get it right, broad.

  • Tye689

    STUPID BITCH! YOU KNOW NOTHING!

    SNIKT!

  • Glen

    In the middle searching old friends, found your website.Just passing by.By the way, your website have great content! :)

  • Bobby

    Father Scott Fitzgerald became a priest to disguise his true first name was Francis! I think his parents hated him so much for being born old that they gave him a girls name! He had a hard life with the disease and all and my dad says he couldn’t stand that E. Hemmings Way could write better magazines. He drank alot with the jazz people and then he married a lady named Xelda I think he married her becuse he felt sorry for her becuse she was stuck with an ugly name too! Why couldn’t her parents just maim her like Tiffany or Brittaney or Caitlin or a pretty name?

  • http://wtflolomgrofl.com Dan

    Hehe… Nice!

  • uppala mahesh

    My dear friend this movie is not about to talk about a desease, It contains a great phylosophy behind that. That is the great truth about “change” Even if you born normal way or the other way like Benjemin Button” there is no mercy from change. Nothing is permanent we can’t change this change. It is happening all the time nothing is permenent. We can not keep anything without changing.Brad Pitt has given a chance to understand this universal truth.This is what the Lord budda preached some 2500 years ago.

  • Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhrri

    ummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm there are no police looking for him…you make no sense…..hmmmmm wow

  • cee cee

    i thnk benjamin button was an extremely GREAT movie… i loved everythng about it… my favorite part was toward the end when he starts to turn into a little boy and his wife moves into the opranage to take care of him bkuz he’s gettin younger… i thought that part was really touchin and it shows the true meaning of vowels… to have and to hold until death due us part… i thnk everyone that took part in the movie did an excellent job… i jus have one question is it based on a true story?

  • J. Bean

    My dear girl…. Take a English class for starters. F. Scott Gerald was not a priest, nor did he suffer from an aging disease. He was a writer, who wrote among many things, The Curios Case of Benjamin Button. Other than the name of our main charter and the fact that Benjamin was born a old man, there are not much other similarity’s from the short story from the movie. My advise is to first take the Intellectual out of your name and put Fictional.

  • http://blog.seattlepi.nwsource.com/movielady/ Movielady

    So the “F” stands for “Father.” I was wondering about that.

  • Ann

    I agree with RJ and J. Bean, you totally missed the point of this movie and your review is not only completely off, as well as odd, it is inaccurate about the movie itself as well as the facts surrounding the original story.

  • MichaellaS

    tks for the effort you put in here I appreciate it!

  • mothership

    This is awesome! I LOVE your work. Cracks me up soooo hard.

  • Coocoo Bananas!

    Hey. she made me laugh.. and you have bad grammar. dick.